Menu
Symphony No. 7 in E Major

Symphony No. 7 in E Major

Symphony No. 7 in E Major
There is only one version of the Symphony No. 7, but there are differences between the editions prepared by Robert Haas and Leopold Nowak. The primary difference is the inclusion of the cymbals in the Adagio in the Nowak edition.

  1. Note 1: The cymbal crash, triangle roll, and tympani.
  2. Note 2: Delays the onset of the pizzicato strings at the end of the Adagio for one measure (waiting for the horns to finish their melody, as in Haas.)
  3. Note 3: Pure Nowak.
  4. Note 4: Mixture of Haas and Nowak.
  5. Note 5: Omits cymbal crash and triangle roll but keeps the tympani part at the same place.
  6. Note 6: Just before rehearsal letter A (m. 24) and just before the second statement of the main theme, there is a note in the horn part from the original printed (Gutmann) score and Redlich's edition.
  7. Note 7: At rehearsal letter D (m. 103) one of the horns plays a few notes from the 1885 edition or Nowak.
  8. Note 8: Rehearsal letter E (m. 123-130). A horn accompanies the strings at first (Haas). A few seconds later when the trombones and tuba come in, they enter a few measures sooner (from Haas).
  9. Note 9: Shortly after rehearsal letter G (mm. 148-149), only one trumpet is playing at this point (from Haas). In 1885/Nowak, the trumpet is accompanied by a note held by the woodwinds. (Wand, in his NDRSO recording, has the horns hold this note.)


Notes by Jose Marques   Timed Analysis by William Carragan



page 1 out of 30 next page

Symphony No. 7 in E Major
1884/85 Version. Ed.Paul Hawkshaw) (2024)

Poschner, Markus
Austrian Radio (ORF) Symphony Orchestra
5-8/12/23: Capriccio CD C8091
59:20
17:55
20:03
9:31
11:51


Symphony No. 7 in E Major
1885 Original Version. Ed. Robert Haas [1944]

Abravanel, Maurice
Utah Symphony Orchestra
Oct-73: Disco Archivia DA-479
61:10
18:36
21:36
9:17
11:48
Arming, Christian
New Japan Philharmonic Orchestra
9-10/9/11: Fontec FOCD 6013
66:30
21:05
22:46
9:27
12:43
Asahina, Takashi
Japan Philharmonic Orchestra
10/12/1968: Exton CD OVCL 00160
65:09
20:47
22:03
9:34
12:44
Asahina, Takashi
New Japan Philharmonic Orchestra
8/9/1992: Fontec CD FOCD 9053/55
68:14
21:55
23:45
8:46
12:49
8/9/1992: Fontec CD FOCD 9063
68:14
21:55
23:45
8:46
12:49
8/9/1992: Fontec CD FOCD 9341
68:14
21:55
23:45
8:46
12:49
8/9/1992: King International Blu-Ray KKC-90006/7
68:14
21:55
23:45
8:46
12:49
8/9/1992: SHA-EI DVD SHHP-0001
68:14
21:55
23:45
8:46
12:49
8/9/1992: Tower Records - Fontec SACD TWFS 90016/17
68:14
21:55
23:45
8:46
12:49
Asahina, Takashi
Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra
10/5/2001: Exton CD OVCL-00068
64:00
21:18
20:40
8:35
12:30
10/5/2001: Exton SACD OVCL-00315
64:00
21:18
20:40
8:35
12:30
10/5/2001: Tower Records / Exton SACD Set OVEP-00006
64:00
21:18
20:40
8:35
12:30
Asahina, Takashi
Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra
12/10/1975: Altus ALT LP 094
71:30
22:49
25:01
9:34
14:04
12/10/1975: Altus ALT LP 094
71:30
22:49
25:01
9:34
14:04
12/10/1975: Altus CD ALT 337
71:30
22:49
25:01
9:34
14:04
12/10/1975: Altus/Tower Records SACD ATKSA 1010
71:30
22:49
25:01
9:34
14:04
12/10/1975: JVC CD VDC-1214
71:30
22:49
25:01
9:33
14:03
Asahina, Takashi
Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra
13/9/83: JVC CD JMXR 30006
64:40
19:53
22:25
9:12
13:01
13/9/83: JVC CD VDC 1067
64:40
19:53
22:25
9:12
13:01
13/9/83: JVC CD VDC 511
64:40
19:53
22:25
9:12
13:01
13/9/83: JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set)
64:40
19:53
22:25
9:12
13:01
13/9/83: JVC CD VICC 60281-91 (full set)
64:40
19:53
22:25
9:12
13:01
13/9/83: Tower Records SACD Set GCAC-1018-20
64:40
19:53
22:25
9:12
13:01
Asahina, Takashi
Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra
14/4/76: Jean Jean CD JJGD-2001-2017 (reissue)
67:09
20:50
23:10
9:34
13:10
14/4/76: Jean-Jean CD JJ008-019(full set)
67:09
20:50
23:10
9:34
13:10
Asahina, Takashi
Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra
19/9/83: JVC 7' LP PRA-11335 (excerpt)
4:36
Asahina, Takashi
Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra
26/10/1975: Altus CD ALT 219
68:47
21:55
23:35
9:36
13:41
26/10/1975: Altus/Tower Records SACD ATKSA 1010
68:47
21:55
23:35
9:36
13:41
Asahina, Takashi
Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra
27-29/9/92: Canyon SACD PCCL 60020
63:14
20:56
21:13
8:07
12:45
27-29/9/92: Pony Canyon CD PCCL 00178
63:14
20:56
21:13
8:07
12:45
27-29/9/92: Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00475
63:14
20:56
21:13
8:07
12:45
Asahina, Takashi
Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra
31/7/97: Kojima CD LMCD-1549
67:05
21:59
22:34
9:05
13:27
Asahina, Takashi
Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra
5/11/1999: Exton DVD OVBC00001
67:00
22:36
22:07
9:24
12:52
Asahina, Takashi
Tokyo Metropolitan Symphony Orchestra
24/10/97: Fontec FOCD 9132
69:30
23:05
23:46
9:27
13:12
24/10/97: Fontec FOCD 9364
69:30
23:05
23:46
9:27
13:12
24/10/97: Tower Records SACD TWFS90014-15
69:30
23:05
23:46
9:27
13:12
Asahina, Takashi
Tokyo Metropolitan Symphony Orchestra
25/5/01: Fontec FOCD 9158
63:00
21:46
20:06
8:44
12:21
25/5/01: Fontec FOCD 9367
63:00
21:46
20:06
8:44
12:21
25/5/01: Tower Records SACD TWFS90014-15
63:00
21:46
20:06
8:44
12:21
Asahina, Takashi
Tokyo Metropolitan Symphony Orchestra
5/5/78: Tobu TBRCD 0170-2
67:23
21:24
23:54
9:42
12:23
Asahina, Takashi
Tokyo Symphony Orchestra
23/4/94: Canyon Classics CD PCCL 0362
69:02
22:21
22:09
9:38
14:52
23/4/94: Canyon Classics CD PCCL 0517
69:02
22:21
22:09
9:38
14:52
23/4/94: Tower / Exton Hybrid SACD Set OVEP-00013
69:02
22:21
22:09
9:38
14:52
Asahina, Takashi
Tokyo Symphony Orchestra
26/9/80: JVC LP SJX 1151/9
74:00
23:28
27:02
9:34
13:53
26/9/80: Tower Records SACD Set CGAC-1021-2
74:00
23:28
27:02
9:34
13:53
26/9/80: Tower Records SACD Set GCAC 1021
74:00
23:28
27:02
9:34
13:53
26/9/80: Tower Records Victor Collection CD NCS 631-634
74:00
23:28
27:02
9:34
13:53
Barenboim, Daniel
Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra
3/5/86: Eternities ETCD 174-S
67:29
20:56
22:55
10:21
13:17
Blomstedt, Herbert
Bamberg Symphony Orchestra
21/12/08: Antec Music AM 3126
68:30
21:17
24:16
10:00
12:39


page 1 out of 30 next page