Menu
Symphony No. 7 in E Major

Symphony No. 7 in E Major

Symphony No. 7 in E Major
There is only one version of the Symphony No. 7, but there are differences between the editions prepared by Robert Haas and Leopold Nowak. The primary difference is the inclusion of the cymbals in the Adagio in the Nowak edition.

  1. Note 1: The cymbal crash, triangle roll, and tympani.
  2. Note 2: Delays the onset of the pizzicato strings at the end of the Adagio for one measure (waiting for the horns to finish their melody, as in Haas.)
  3. Note 3: Pure Nowak.
  4. Note 4: Mixture of Haas and Nowak.
  5. Note 5: Omits cymbal crash and triangle roll but keeps the tympani part at the same place.
  6. Note 6: Just before rehearsal letter A (m. 24) and just before the second statement of the main theme, there is a note in the horn part from the original printed (Gutmann) score and Redlich's edition.
  7. Note 7: At rehearsal letter D (m. 103) one of the horns plays a few notes from the 1885 edition or Nowak.
  8. Note 8: Rehearsal letter E (m. 123-130). A horn accompanies the strings at first (Haas). A few seconds later when the trombones and tuba come in, they enter a few measures sooner (from Haas).
  9. Note 9: Shortly after rehearsal letter G (mm. 148-149), only one trumpet is playing at this point (from Haas). In 1885/Nowak, the trumpet is accompanied by a note held by the woodwinds. (Wand, in his NDRSO recording, has the horns hold this note.)


Notes by Jose Marques   Timed Analysis by William Carragan




page 6 out of 30 previous page next page

Symphony No. 7 in E Major
1885 Original Version. Ed. Robert Haas [1944]

Rosbaud, Hans
Southwest German Radio Symphony Orchestra
27 and 30/12/57: Christophorus LP FGLP 77637
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Concerto Royale 206218
62:55
18:57
21:30
10:46
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Documents 221922-205
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Documents CD 221922
62:54
18:59
21:29
10:45
11:36
27 and 30/12/57: Eurodisc LP 70 508 XK
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Fono-Ring FGLP 77 637
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Forgotten Records FR 1080
63:30
19:02
21:34
10:50
11:44
27 and 30/12/57: High Definition Tape Transfers
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: I Grandi della Musica Classica CD
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Mediaphon CD 22.314
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Memories Reverence MR-2516
63:02
19:03
21:33
10:48
11:37
27 and 30/12/57: Orbis Eurodisc LP 72743
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Parnass / Opera LP 71845
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Quadromania CD set 222116
63:09
19:05
21:33
10:47
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: SchallplattenGuild Gutenberg LP AGL 1032
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: SWR Classics Set SWR 19043CD
63:39
19:08
21:36
10:47
11:49
27 and 30/12/57: Turnabout LP TV 34083
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Tuxedo CD TUXCD 1207
62:51
18:54
21:26
10:45
11:38
27 and 30/12/57: Vox CD CDX2 5518
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Vox LP 10.750
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Vox LP SVBX 5117
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Vox LP SVBX 5117
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Vox LP VBX 117
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: Vox STPL 10752
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40
27 and 30/12/57: ZYX CD CAB-CD 10325
62:54
18:59
21:29
10:45
11:36
27 and 30/12/57: ZYX CD CLA 10053
62:54
18:59
21:29
10:45
11:36
27 and 30/12/57: ZYX CD MVD 1013-2
62:54
18:59
21:29
10:45
11:36
27 and 30/12/57: ZYX Classics CD CLS-4337
62:54
18:59
21:29
10:45
11:36
Rozhdestvensky, Gennadi
USSR Ministry of Culture Orchestra
1985: Japan BMG/Melodiya CD BVCX38011/12
64:21
19:49
21:06
10:30
12:33
1985: Japan Victor CD VDC 1407
64:04
19:52
21:09
10:32
12:31
1985: Melodiya LP C10 23763001
64:04
19:52
21:09
10:32
12:31
1985: Venezia CDVE 04240 (boxed set)
64:21
19:49
21:06
10:30
12:33
1985: Venezia CDVE 04368 (boxed set)
64:21
19:49
21:06
10:30
12:33
1985: Venezia Set CDVE 44004
64:21
19:49
21:06
10:30
12:33
Schmidt-Isserstedt, Hans
Chicago Symphony Orchestra
18/4/68: CRQ Editions CRQ CD 287-288
62:39
19:37
21:33
10:17
11:12
Schmidt-Isserstedt, Hans
NDR Symphony Orchestra
28/10/68: Altus CD TALT-019
59:18
18:34
20:23
9:19
11:02
28/10/68: Altus LP TALTLP-031
59:18
18:34
20:23
9:19
11:02
28/10/68: Tahra CD 9901/2
59:40
18:34
20:25
9:20
11:02
Seaman, Christopher
National Youth Orchestra (UK)
24/3/81: National Youth Orchestra Cassette NYO-100
62:26
19:42
21:32
9:31
11:40
Shimono, Tatsuya
Hiroshima Symphony Orchestra
27/5/22: Brain Music CD OSBR 39005
63:52
19:52
22:01
9:36
12:23
Tanaka, Yoshikazu
Bruckner Orchestra Nagoya
29/6/97: Voicelle CD BON-003/004
62:45
19:30
20:51
9:27
12:29
Tang, Muhai
Queensland Symphony Orchestra
22-23/11/96: ABC Classics CD 456 664-2
60:45
19:28
21:12
8:48
11:01
22-23/11/96: ABC Classics CD 476-4119
60:45
19:28
21:12
8:48
11:01
Thielemann, Christian
Staatskapelle Dresden
1/9/2012: Opus Arte Blu-Ray OA BD7127D
70:12
22:44
23:02
9:50
13:34
1/9/2012: Opus Arte DVD OA 1115D
70:12
22:44
23:02
9:50
13:34
Thielemann, Christian
Staatskapelle Dresden
2/9/12: Profil CD PH 15013
69:49
23:02
23:12
10:00
13:35
2/9/12: Profil CD PH 20021
69:49
23:02
23:12
10:00
13:35
Tintner, Georg
Royal Scottish National Orchestra
6-7/5/97: Avex Classics AVCL25621
65:54
20:06
21:55
10:47
12:53
6-7/5/97: Naxos CD 8.554269
65:54
20:06
21:55
10:47
12:53
6-7/5/97: Naxos CD Set 8.501101
65:54
20:06
21:55
10:47
12:53


page 6 out of 30 previous page next page