Menu
Symphony No. 7 in E Major

Symphony No. 7 in E Major

Symphony No. 7 in E Major
There is only one version of the Symphony No. 7, but there are differences between the editions prepared by Robert Haas and Leopold Nowak. The primary difference is the inclusion of the cymbals in the Adagio in the Nowak edition.

  1. Note 1: The cymbal crash, triangle roll, and tympani.
  2. Note 2: Delays the onset of the pizzicato strings at the end of the Adagio for one measure (waiting for the horns to finish their melody, as in Haas.)
  3. Note 3: Pure Nowak.
  4. Note 4: Mixture of Haas and Nowak.
  5. Note 5: Omits cymbal crash and triangle roll but keeps the tympani part at the same place.
  6. Note 6: Just before rehearsal letter A (m. 24) and just before the second statement of the main theme, there is a note in the horn part from the original printed (Gutmann) score and Redlich's edition.
  7. Note 7: At rehearsal letter D (m. 103) one of the horns plays a few notes from the 1885 edition or Nowak.
  8. Note 8: Rehearsal letter E (m. 123-130). A horn accompanies the strings at first (Haas). A few seconds later when the trombones and tuba come in, they enter a few measures sooner (from Haas).
  9. Note 9: Shortly after rehearsal letter G (mm. 148-149), only one trumpet is playing at this point (from Haas). In 1885/Nowak, the trumpet is accompanied by a note held by the woodwinds. (Wand, in his NDRSO recording, has the horns hold this note.)


Notes by Jose Marques   Timed Analysis by William Carragan




page 5 out of 30 previous page next page

Symphony No. 7 in E Major
1885 Original Version. Ed. Robert Haas [1944]

Masur, Kurt
New York Philharmonic Orchestra
13/9/91: Teldec CD 73243
63:28
20:04
21:00
9:35
12:22
13/9/91: Teldec VHS
63:28
20:04
21:00
9:35
12:22
Masur, Kurt
Schleswig Holstein Festival Orchestra
2003: Orchestra CD DSM 37677150
62:30
19:13
19:51
9:28
13:26
Masur, Kurt
Schleswig Holstein Festival Orchestra
25/8/03: En Larmes 03-423
63:00
19:21
20:14
9:50
13:10
Matacic, Lovro von
Slovene Philharmonic Orchestra
19-22/6/84: Columbia Music Management COCQ84428
66:20
20:04
22:00
10:42
13:00
19-22/6/84: Denon 47 CO-2033-34
66:20
20:04
22:00
10:42
13:00
19-22/6/84: Denon CO-2035
66:20
20:04
22:00
10:42
13:00
19-22/6/84: Jugoton LP LD 1272
66:30
20:14
22:10
10:52
13:09
19-22/6/84: Slovenski Philharmonic CD 900041/2
66:30
20:14
22:10
10:52
13:09
Moralt (Pseudonym), Rudolf
Vienna Symphony Orchestra
: Tuxedo CD TUXCD1207
Moriguchi, Shinji
Bruckner Orchestra Nagoya
28/6/15: Voicelle CD BON-039/40
67:07
20:50
22:57
10:06
13:14
Mravinsky, Evgeni
Leningrad Philharmonic Orchestra
25/2/67: EMI CD 5 75953 2
61:20
21:20
18:59
9:09
11:35
25/2/67: Russian Disc CD 10 911
61:23
21:23
19:02
9:09
11:34
25/2/67: Urania CD Set WS 121.378
66:21
23:19
20:41
9:57
12:22
25/2/67: Venezia CD CDVE 03215
61:23
21:23
19:02
9:09
11:34
25/2/67: Venezia CD set CDVE 4258
61:23
21:23
19:02
9:09
11:34
25/2/67: Venezia CD set CDVE 4339
61:23
21:23
19:02
9:09
11:34
Muti, Riccardo
Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra
5/5/1996: Belsona Classics BECL 0015/0016
64:42
20:36
22:27
9:42
11:51
5/5/1996: The Uphill Road in Cleveland URC 0067
64:42
20:36
22:27
9:42
11:51
Nelsons, Andris
Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra
3/2018: DGG CD 479 8494
69:35
21:41
25:07
9:43
13:04
3/2018: DGG CD Set 486 4528
69:35
21:41
25:07
9:43
13:04
3/2018: DGG SACD Set UCGG 9219/28
69:35
21:41
25:07
9:43
13:04
Nishiwaki, Yoshinori
Der Ring Tokyo Orchestra
4/9/19: Fine NF SACD NF65809
63:51
20:12
21:44
9:08
12:45
Noguchi, Takeo
Furtwaengler Institute Philharmonic - Tokyo
1997: Tokyo Wing CD WCD118
60:39
19:54
19:31
8:58
12:16
Otaka, Tadaaki
Osaka Philharmonic
24/1/23: Fontec CD FOCD 9895
61:59
20:44
19:51
9:06
12:18
Otaka, Tadaaki
Sapporo Symphony Orchestra
18-19/5/13: Fontec Hybrid SACD FOCD 9620
65:36
21:55
21:21
9:24
12:37
Otaka, Tadaaki
Tokyo Philharmonic
22/9/87: Live Notes CD WWCC 7211
65:30
21:29
22:07
9:25
12:25
Otterloo, Willem van
Vienna Symphony Orchestra
23-26/3/54: Challenge Records CD Set CC 72383
64:30
18:24
24:54
9:43
11:05
23-26/3/54: Epic LP SC 6006
64:00
18:24
24:54
9:43
11:05
23-26/3/54: Forgotten Records CD FR 144
64:36
18:32
25:02
9:50
11:08
23-26/3/54: Philips LP A00249-50L
64:30
18:24
24:54
9:43
11:05
Otterloo, Willen van
Netherlands Radio Philharmonic Orchestra
2/4/58: Vibrato CD VHL-505
63:00
18:14
23:57
9:45
11:01
Oue, Eiji
Osaka Philharmonic Orchestra
17-18/2/06: Fontec Hybrid SACD FOCD 9581
64:40
20:48
21:48
9:34
12:30
Ozawa, Seiji
Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra
22/6/88: Berlin Philharmonic Ozawa CD set BPHR 240431
64:47
20:43
22:23
9:39
12:02
Pasquet, Nicolas
Pecs Symphony Orchestra
14/12/94: Do-La Studio DLCD 066
66:15
18:41
22:12
9:49
12:15
Rickenbacher, Karl Anton
National Youth Orchestra of Catalinia
8/1/13: Dirigent DIR-1199
63:47
19:40
21:52
9:24
12:41
Rieger, Fritz
Orchestra National de lORTF
8/4/70: St. Laurent Studio CD YSL-1178
60:01
18:45
19:50
9:20
12:06
Roegner, Heinz
Berlin Radio Symphony Orchestra (East)
10/1983: Avex Classics SACD AVCL25297
59:15
18:52
18:50
9:16
12:02
10/1983: Berlin Classics 185852
59:15
18:52
18:50
9:16
12:02
10/1983: Berlin Classics CD 301620
59:15
18:52
18:50
9:16
12:02
10/1983: Brilliant Classics Set 94686
59:15
18:52
18:50
9:16
12:02
10/1983: Deutsche Schallplatten Amabile 01
59:15
18:52
18:50
9:16
12:02
10/1983: Deutsche Schallplatten CD TKCC-30
59:15
18:52
18:50
9:16
12:02
10/1983: Eterna CD BC3016-2
59:15
18:52
18:50
9:16
12:02
10/1983: King KICC 9468
59:15
18:52
18:50
9:16
12:02
10/1983: King Records CD KICC 3661
59:15
18:52
18:50
9:16
12:02
10/1983: Tower Berlin Classics hybrid SACD 303327BC
59:12
18:55
18:54
9:19
12:04
Roegner, Heinz
Berlin Radio Symphony Orchestra (East)
13/10/79: Weitblick CD Set SSS0166/160-2
58:08
18:53
18:38
9:18
11:19
Rosbaud, Hans
Southwest German Radio Symphony Orchestra
27 and 30/12/57: Andromeda ANDRCD 9034
63:02
19:03
21:33
10:48
11:37
27 and 30/12/57: Cantus Classic CD 8.00022
63:09
19:01
21:31
10:44
11:40


page 5 out of 30 previous page next page