Menu
Symphony No. 7 in E Major

Symphony No. 7 in E Major

Symphony No. 7 in E Major
There is only one version of the Symphony No. 7, but there are differences between the editions prepared by Robert Haas and Leopold Nowak. The primary difference is the inclusion of the cymbals in the Adagio in the Nowak edition.

  1. Note 1: The cymbal crash, triangle roll, and tympani.
  2. Note 2: Delays the onset of the pizzicato strings at the end of the Adagio for one measure (waiting for the horns to finish their melody, as in Haas.)
  3. Note 3: Pure Nowak.
  4. Note 4: Mixture of Haas and Nowak.
  5. Note 5: Omits cymbal crash and triangle roll but keeps the tympani part at the same place.
  6. Note 6: Just before rehearsal letter A (m. 24) and just before the second statement of the main theme, there is a note in the horn part from the original printed (Gutmann) score and Redlich's edition.
  7. Note 7: At rehearsal letter D (m. 103) one of the horns plays a few notes from the 1885 edition or Nowak.
  8. Note 8: Rehearsal letter E (m. 123-130). A horn accompanies the strings at first (Haas). A few seconds later when the trombones and tuba come in, they enter a few measures sooner (from Haas).
  9. Note 9: Shortly after rehearsal letter G (mm. 148-149), only one trumpet is playing at this point (from Haas). In 1885/Nowak, the trumpet is accompanied by a note held by the woodwinds. (Wand, in his NDRSO recording, has the horns hold this note.)


Notes by Jose Marques   Timed Analysis by William Carragan




page 4 out of 30 previous page next page

Symphony No. 7 in E Major
1885 Original Version. Ed. Robert Haas [1944]

Karajan, Herbert von
Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra
Apr-89: DG CD UCCG-90067
66:15
19:47
23:12
10:10
12:42
Apr-89: El Mundo - Lo Mejor De # 5
66:15
19:47
23:12
10:10
12:42
Apr-89: Universal (Japan) DGG UCCG 90667
66:15
19:47
23:12
10:10
12:42
Apr-89: Universal Classics UCCG 9858
66:15
19:47
23:12
10:10
12:42
Apr-89: Universal Classics UCCG51011
66:15
19:47
23:12
10:10
12:42
Apr-89: Universal Classics UCCG51011
66:15
19:47
23:12
10:10
12:42
Apr-89: Universal Classics UCCG70069
66:15
19:47
23:12
10:10
12:42
Kegel, Herbert
Leipzig Radio Symphony Orchestra
17-28/5/71: Ode Classics CD 1019
67:00
20:42
23:15
10:29
12:22
17-28/5/71: ODE Classics CD ODCLBOX3
67:00
20:42
23:15
10:29
12:22
17-28/5/71: Weitblick SSS0118
67:00
20:42
23:15
10:29
12:22
Kegel, Herbert
Leipzig Radio Symphony Orchestra
9/5/1961: Ode Classics CD 1018
66:15
19:56
22:22
9:40
12:08
Keilberth, Joseph
NHK Symphony Orchestra
1/5/1968: King CD KICC 3052
59:30
19:01
18:00
10:22
11:55
1/5/1968: Seven Seas 270E 18
59:30
19:01
18:00
10:22
11:55
Kempe, Rudolf
Stockholm Philharmonic Orchestra
9/4/1975: Stockholm Philharmonic Set RSPO 1000-2
60:30
18:53
20:42
9:21
11:25
9/4/1975: World Music Express WME-CDR-1006.
58:07
18:11
19:54
8:55
10:42
Klemperer, Otto
BBC Symphony Orchestra
2-3/12/55: Archiphon CD WU-147
57:11
17:20
18:10
8:33
11:47
2-3/12/55: ICA Classics Set ICAC 5145
57:17
17:45
18:34
8:56
12:02
Koehler, Lutz
Symphony Orchestra of the UdK Berlin
14/5/10: Universitat der Kunst Berlin CD 2010
22:27
Komatsu, Kazuhiko
Bruckner Orchestra Nagoya
23/6/02: Voicelle CD BON-014/015
66:00
21:02
23:08
9:37
12:14
Konwitschny, Franz
Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra
20-22/6/58: Berlin Classics CD 2114-2
65:21
20:39
21:32
10:15
12:43
20-22/6/58: Eterna LP 8 20 060-061
65:21
20:39
21:32
10:15
12:43
20-22/6/58: Eterna LP 8 25 060-061
65:20
20:45
21:45
10:25
12:10
20-22/6/58: Eurodisc LP 86 367 XHK
65:21
20:39
21:32
10:15
12:43
20-22/6/58: Eurodisc LP OC 7112 (Japan)
65:21
20:39
21:32
10:15
12:43
20-22/6/58: Memories Reverence CD Set MR 2314/2319
65:45
20:56
21:42
10:19
12:48
Kotani, Seiichi
Tachikawa Orchestra
11/6/2000: Orchestra CD (39th Concert)
72:15
22:46
25:55
11:07
12:38
Lee, Dong-Ho
Jeju Philharmonic Orchestra
13/4/07: Jeju Philharmonic CD JPO-080
67:54
20:06
26:10
9:32
12:04
Lee, Dong-Ho
Jeju Philharmonic Orchestra
21/4/07: Jeju Philharmonic DVD JPO-003
68:15
20:11
26:21:00
9:15
12:14
Loughran, James
Aarhus Symphony Orchestra
28/4/05: Danacord DACOCD 655
67:28
21:04
23:28
10:06
12:20
Mantle, Neil
Scottish Sinfonia
26/11/17: Scottish Sinfonia CD SS023
58:49
18:46
19:16
9:34
11:13
Martin Lukas, Meister
Hessian Youth Symphony Orchestra
5/4/09: Orchestra CD
61:45
19:41
21:14
9:12
11:32
Masur, Kurt
Berlin Staatskapelle
17/11/67: Orchestral Concert CD 6/2009
63:19
19:07
22:15
9:32
12:24
Masur, Kurt
French National Orchestra
12/5/2005: Karna Musik KA-240M
63:00
19:13
20:12
9:53
13:13
Masur, Kurt
French National Orchestra
17/9/07: Dirigent DIR-0185
65:00
19:51
21:24
10:07
13:22
17/9/07: Harvest Classics HC 06126
65:00
19:51
21:24
10:07
13:22
Masur, Kurt
French National Orchestra and London Philharmonic
18/7/07: Sun Jay Classics SUCD-42-K
62:00
19:20
20:01
9:30
12:52
Masur, Kurt
Israel Philharmonic Orchestra
3/1995: Helicon Classics CD 02-9654
63:14
20:05
21:16
9:16
12:47
Masur, Kurt
Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra
12/6/1974: Denon CD 28 C37-13
65:00
19:55
21:55
10:00
13:10
12/6/1974: Denon CD COCO80100 full set
65:00
19:55
21:55
10:00
13:10
12/6/1974: Eterna LP 826 759/760
65:00
19:55
21:55
10:00
13:10
12/6/1974: Eterna LP 827453 (4th mvt. only)
13:10
12/6/1974: Eurodisc CD 69227 (full set)
65:00
19:55
21:55
10:00
13:10
12/6/1974: Eurodisc LP 27913XGK
65:00
19:55
21:55
10:00
13:10
12/6/1974: Eurodisc LP 301 587-467 (full set
65:00
19:55
21:55
10:00
13:10
12/6/1974: RCA CD 24207
65:00
19:55
21:55
10:00
13:10
12/6/1974: RCA CD 74321 30368-2
65:00
19:55
21:55
10:00
13:10
12/6/1974: RCA CD 82876.60395 full set
65:00
19:55
21:55
10:00
13:10
12/6/1974: RCA CD 88843063682 (full set)
65:00
19:55
21:55
10:00
13:10
Masur, Kurt
New York Philharmonic Orchestra
13/9/91: Teldec Apex CD 65942-2
63:17
20:04
21:00
9:35
12:22
13/9/91: Teldec CD 3984-21338-2
63:28
20:04
21:00
9:35
12:22


page 4 out of 30 previous page next page