Menu
Symphony No. 7 in E Major

Symphony No. 7 in E Major

Symphony No. 7 in E Major
There is only one version of the Symphony No. 7, but there are differences between the editions prepared by Robert Haas and Leopold Nowak. The primary difference is the inclusion of the cymbals in the Adagio in the Nowak edition.

  1. Note 1: The cymbal crash, triangle roll, and tympani.
  2. Note 2: Delays the onset of the pizzicato strings at the end of the Adagio for one measure (waiting for the horns to finish their melody, as in Haas.)
  3. Note 3: Pure Nowak.
  4. Note 4: Mixture of Haas and Nowak.
  5. Note 5: Omits cymbal crash and triangle roll but keeps the tympani part at the same place.
  6. Note 6: Just before rehearsal letter A (m. 24) and just before the second statement of the main theme, there is a note in the horn part from the original printed (Gutmann) score and Redlich's edition.
  7. Note 7: At rehearsal letter D (m. 103) one of the horns plays a few notes from the 1885 edition or Nowak.
  8. Note 8: Rehearsal letter E (m. 123-130). A horn accompanies the strings at first (Haas). A few seconds later when the trombones and tuba come in, they enter a few measures sooner (from Haas).
  9. Note 9: Shortly after rehearsal letter G (mm. 148-149), only one trumpet is playing at this point (from Haas). In 1885/Nowak, the trumpet is accompanied by a note held by the woodwinds. (Wand, in his NDRSO recording, has the horns hold this note.)


Notes by Jose Marques   Timed Analysis by William Carragan




page 2 out of 30 previous page next page

Symphony No. 7 in E Major
1885 Original Version. Ed. Robert Haas [1944]

Blomstedt, Herbert
Bamberg Symphony Orchestra
21/12/08: SunJay Classics SUCD-170K
68:30
21:17
24:16
10:00
12:39
Blomstedt, Herbert
Bamberg Symphony Orchestra
22/10/16: Dirigent CD DIR-1943
68:30
21:57
24:12
9:44
12:37
Blomstedt, Herbert
Boston Symphony Orchestra
26/8/06: Karna Musik KA-318M
67:30
21:27
24:02
9:38
12:12
Blomstedt, Herbert
Danish National Radio Symphony Orchestra
14/10/07: DRS DVD 2.110416
70:17
22:15
24:51
10:03
13:08
Blomstedt, Herbert
Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra
23-25/11/06: Accentus CD Set ACC 80575
68:00
22:00
24:22
10:08
13:14
23-25/11/06: Querstand SACD Set VKJK 1230
68:00
22:00
24:22
10:08
13:14
23-25/11/06: Querstand SACD VKJK 0708
68:00
22:00
24:22
10:08
13:14
Blomstedt, Herbert
Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra
25/11/06: Karna Musik KA-379M
67:58
21:05
24:17
9:56
12:40
25/11/06: The Uphill Road in Cleveland URC 0182
67:58
21:05
24:17
9:56
12:40
Blomstedt, Herbert
NDR Symphony Orchestra
9/1/1998: En Larmes 01-34
67:45
21:15
24:35
9:34
12:15
9/1/1998: Live Supreme CD LSU-1077
67:45
21:15
24:35
9:34
12:15
Blomstedt, Herbert
Staatskapelle Dresden
12/6/1979: Lucky Ball LB 0075
65:30
20:26
23:35
9:13
12:16
Blomstedt, Herbert
Staatskapelle Dresden
30/6-3/7/80: Dal Segno DSPRCD046
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
30/6-3/7/80: Denon CD 38C37-7286
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
30/6-3/7/80: Denon CD C37-7419
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
30/6-3/7/80: Denon CD COCO-70489
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
30/6-3/7/80: Denon CD COCO-73137
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
30/6-3/7/80: Denon CD COCO-85054
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
30/6-3/7/80: Denon CD COCO-85405
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
30/6-3/7/80: Denon CD COCQ-85405
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
30/6-3/7/80: Denon LP 7375/6
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
30/6-3/7/80: Deutsche Schallplatten CD 329 268
67:55
21:10
24:30
9:38
12:26
30/6-3/7/80: Eterna LP 729268
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
30/6-3/7/80: MDG CD 650 2150-2
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
30/6-3/7/80: Tower / Denon SACD TWSA 1119-20
67:32
21:03
24:30
9:36
12:23
Blomstedt, Herbert
Swedish Radio Symphony Orchestra
19/1/07: Harvest Classics HC-06096
68:15
21:07
23:50
10:00
12:58
19/1/07: SunJay CD SUCD-58K
68:15
21:07
23:50
10:00
12:58
19/1/07: SunJay CD SUCD-82K
68:15
21:07
23:50
10:00
12:58
Braem, Thuering
Junge Philharmonic Zentralschweiz
5-7/11/94: Luzern Konservatorium CD
70:39
22:00
25:17
10:32
12:48
Brogli-Sacher, Roman
Hansestadt Philharmonic Orch. Luebeck
3-4/10/04: Orchestra Friends OF-1005
60:00
19:12
18:03
9:12
12:55
Buente, C. A.
Berlin Symphony Orchestra
17/3/59: Bella Musica CD BM 31.2441
68:30
20:35
24:33
10:48
12:32
17/3/59: Buente CD
68:30
20:35
24:33
10:48
12:32
Buente, C. A.
Berlin Symphony Orchestra
25/12/54: Buente CD
18:41
21:23
9:45
Buente, C. A.
Kansai Philharmonic Orchestra Osaka
11/5/1994: Buente CD
69:17
20:44
24:39
10:53
12:56
Carignani, Paolo
Frankfurt Museum Orchestra
6/6/05: Frankfurt Museum CD SP 88106
61:29
20:40
20:36
8:39
11:34
Chung, Jae-Dong
Korean Symphony Orchestra
7/5/05: KBS Media DVD
70:54
22:42
24:42
10:44
12:46
d'Avalos, Francesco
Philharmonia Orchestra
1988: ASV CD 6154
61:40
19:30
21:10
9:02
11:54
1988: ASV CD 625
61:40
19:30
21:10
9:02
11:54
Durjan'narc, Ogan
Leipzig Radio Symphony Orchestra
1963: Durjan'narc DVD # 14
64:30
19:52
21:30
9:57
12:56
1963: Lanne Historical Collection LHC-7154
64:30
19:50
21:25
9:52
13:04
Geiger, Stefan
LJO Bremen
10/4/10: LJO Bremen CD 04.2010
58:56
18:16
20:33
8:34
11:32
Haitink, Bernard
BBC Symphony Orchestra
1960's: BBC Transcription CN 0362
60:43
19:01
21:24
9:48
11:15
Hindemith, Paul
Chicago Symphony Orchestra
7/4/1963: CSO CD 'Collector's Choice set'
19:15
7/4/1963: Video Artists International DVD 4237
19:15
7/4/1963: Video Artists International VHS Video 69606
19:15
Kamioka, Toshiyuki
New Japan Philharmonic Orchestra
5 and 8/9/19: Exton Hybrid SACD OVCL-00731
71:56
22:45
25:11
10:40
13:20
Kamioka, Toshiyuki
Sinfonieorchester Wuppertal
8-9/9/07: Denon COCQ 84841
91:00
28:43
33:33
10:07
16:37
8-9/9/07: TDK-MA302
91:00
28:43
33:33
10:07
16:37
Karajan, Herbert von
Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra
1/9/82: St. Laurent Studio CD YSL-1087
63:29
19:28
20:48
10:29
12:44
Karajan, Herbert von
Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra
19/10/70 and 3-4/2/71: Angel LP SC-3779
68:09
21:49
22:54
10:30
12:55


page 2 out of 30 previous page next page