Symphony No. 2 in C Minor

Symphony No. 2 in C Minor
The Symphony No. 2 in C Minor exists in several versions. There is the 1872 First Version and the 1877 Version. Both have been prepared by William Carragan. Robert Haas and Leopold Nowak both prepared editions that are amalgamations of the 1872 and 1877 manuscripts. In addition, William Carragan prepared a 1873 "First Performance" edition and a variant of the score as it existed in 1876. Finally, there is the first published edition that was prepared by Cyrill Hynais in 1892.

Notes by David Griegel   Notes by Jose Marques   Timed Analysis by William Carragan



Symphony No. 2 in C Minor
1872 Finale with the 1876 peroration. Ed. Carragan

20:52


Symphony No. 2 in C Minor
1872 First concept version. Ed. William Carragan [2005]

20/6/10: Dirigent DIR 0851
65:03
19:35
10:41
15:29
19:18
21/1/10: Antec Music C.0107
62:30
18:38
10:16
14:43
18:38
61:02
18:14
9:58
14:25
18:25
17/12/09: Antec Music C.0095
66:08
19:36
10:36
16:10
19:46
17/12/09: Dirigent DIR-0561
66:08
19:36
10:36
16:10
19:46
2-4/10/15: Oehms Classics OC 447
71:36
20:46
11:52
17:09
21:45
22 and 24/5/10: Coviello Classics SACD COV 31015
66:21
17:45
10:00
17:44
20:48
22 and 24/5/10: Coviello Classics SACD Set 31215
66:21
17:45
10:00
17:44
20:48
16/9/07: Harvest Classics HC-06153
69:00
19:45
9:52
18:20
20:51
16/9/07: The Uphill Road in Cleveland URC-0117
69:00
19:45
9:52
18:20
20:51
67:16
19:40
10:59
15:42
20:55
67:16
19:40
10:59
15:42
20:55
71:22
20:50
10:53
18:00
21:19
71:22
20:50
10:53
18:00
21:19
71:22
20:50
10:53
18:00
21:19
12-13/3/06: BMG (Japan) SACD BVCO37439
71:22
20:40
10:47
19:32
20:23
12-13/3/06: Oehms Classics CD OC 026 (Set)
71:22
20:40
10:47
19:32
20:23
12-13/3/06: Oehms Classics SACD OC 614
71:22
20:40
10:47
19:32
20:23


Symphony No. 2 in C Minor
1872/77 Mixed Versions. Ed. Leopold Nowak [1965]

17/4/06: Orchestra CD
50:30
17:07
12:52
6:21
13:56
28/7/78: Vibrato CD VLL-319
57:00
19:01
15:30
6:45
15:18
22/2/05: Arte Nova CD 82876 88883 2
59:05
17:41
15:54
7:51
17:13
22/2/05: BMG CD BVCE 38105
59:05
17:41
15:54
7:51
17:13
22/2/05: Sony Box Set 889854833725
59:05
17:41
15:54
7:51
17:13
29/3/74: World Music Express WME-1048
57:30
18:58
16:07
7:20
14:56
8-10/12/74: Electrola/EMI LP C063-02633
58:22
19:49
16:14
7:08
15:11
8-10/12/74: HMV LP ASD 3146
58:22
19:49
16:14
7:08
15:11
8-10/12/74: Japan EMI CD TOCE-3394
58:22
19:49
16:14
7:08
15:11
8-10/12/74: Testament SBT 1210
58:22
19:49
16:14
7:08
15:11
58:22
19:49
16:14
7:08
15:11
58:22
19:49
16:14
7:08
15:11
3-4/2/14: The Uphill Road in Cleveland URC-0262
54:20
17:37
14:28
6:57
15:18
4/7/08: Antec Music AM 3302
63:15
21:02
16:19
7:29
18:14
Jun-88: Teldec CD 419625
61:16
20:01
16:11
7:13
17:51
Jun-88: Teldec CD 8.44144
61:16
20:01
16:11
7:13
17:51
Jun-88: Teldec LP 243 718-1
61:16
20:01
16:11
7:13
17:51
Jun-88: Teldec LP 6.44144AZ
61:16
20:01
16:11
7:13
17:51
Jun-88: Ultima CD 0927 41399 2
61:16
20:01
16:11
7:13
17:51
14/12/12: Dirigent DIR-1096
63:51
22:18
15:30
7:47
18:14
29/12/66: DG CD 429 079-2 (full set)
51:37
17:52
13:57
6:32
13:16
29/12/66: DG LP 139 132
51:37
17:52
13:57
6:32
13:16
29/12/66: DG LP 139 132
51:37
17:52
13:57
6:32
13:16
51:37
17:52
13:57
6:32
13:16
51:37
17:52
13:57
6:32
13:16
51:37
17:52
13:57
6:32
13:16
52:30
17:56
14:53
6:54
12:47
3-4/7/80: EMI CD 74837 2
52:30
17:56
14:53
6:54
12:47
52:30
17:56
14:53
6:54
12:47
52:30
17:56
14:53
6:54
12:47
3-4/7/80: HMV LP ASD 4081
52:30
17:56
14:53
6:54
12:47
52:30
17:56
14:53
6:54
12:47
12/80 - 1/81: DG CD 415 988-2
60:08
18:16
17:34
6:12
18:06
60:08
18:16
17:34
6:12
18:06
60:08
18:16
17:34
6:12
18:06
12/80 - 1/81: DG CD UCCG 4770
60:08
18:16
17:34
6:12
18:06
12/80 - 1/81: DG LP 2532 063
60:08
18:16
17:34
6:12
18:06
60:08
18:16
17:34
6:12
18:06
60:08
18:16
17:34
6:12
18:06
19-22/3/12: Fontec CD FOCD 6037/9
56:41
16:58
17:16
5:56
16:12
1/2000: Treasures of the Earth TOE-2055
64:45
19:57
18:52
7:35
18:11
27/1/99: Bavarian Radio Set
69:34
21:59
17:32
7:31
22:31
27/1/99: BR Klassik Set 900711
69:34
21:59
17:32
7:31
22:31
15-18/10/09: Dirigent DIR 0537
56:57
19:13
14:56
7:14
15:34
13/4/08: Antec Music AM 3162
57:00
19:17
14:51
6:56
15:40
13/4/08: Dirigent CD DIR-0001
57:00
19:17
14:51
6:56
15:40
13/4/08: SunJay Classics SUCD-93K
57:00
19:17
14:51
6:56
15:40
15/8/16: DGG CD 479 8180
57:22
19:39
15:09
6:57
15:37
26/7/97: Antes Edition SCH.3112 (Complete set)
58:02
18:39
14:49
7:08
16:45
26/7/97: Balance CD Bal-2006-1
58:02
18:39
14:49
7:08
16:45
26/7/97: Membran Music Ltd. 232766 (Complete set)
58:02
18:39
14:49
7:08
16:45
1/8/96 Proms: BBC Transcription CD 1235
65:10
20:35
16:06
8:00
20:22
58:44
18:27
17:04
5:50
17:11
61:38
18:19
16:30
8:09
18:18
61:38
18:19
16:30
8:09
18:18
60:00
17:36
17:17
6:52
18:09
59:02
17:32
18:16
6:13
17:00
55:34
18:09
16:48
6:05
14:32
23-27/4/92: Arte Nova CD 74321 27770-2.
60:33
19:13
16:43
7:40
16:47
23-27/4/92: BMG BVCC 40068
60:33
19:13
16:43
7:40
16:47
18-21/9/07: Challenge Classics Hybrid SACD Set CC72702
62:01
17:51
20:04
6:10
17:53
18-21/9/07: Exton SACD EXCL-00014
62:01
17:51
20:04
6:10
17:53


Symphony No. 2 in C Minor
1872/77 Mixed Versions. Ed. Robert Haas [1938]

57:21
18:05
14:38
6:54
17:36
50:44
15:16
14:16
7:58
13:00
50:44
15:16
14:16
7:58
13:00
50:44
15:16
14:16
7:58
13:00
50:44
15:16
14:16
7:58
13:00
50:44
15:16
14:16
7:58
13:00
16/1/53: Amadeo LP 5041
51:10
15:43
13:20
7:53
13:54
16/1/53: Amanda LP AVRS 12084
51:35
15:50
13:29
7:57
14:02
16/1/53: Bearac CD BRC 2657 (LP transfer)
51:35
15:50
13:29
7:57
14:02
16/1/53: Music and Arts CD Set 1227
51:00
15:43
13:19
7:51
13:52
16/1/53: Philips LP GL5846
51:10
15:43
13:20
7:53
13:54
63:20
18:19
16:44
9:23
18:25
24-27/1/94: Canyon SACD PCCL 60015
71:26
20:02
17:44
12:27
21:13
24-27/1/94: Pony Canyon CD PCCL 00230
71:26
20:02
17:44
12:27
21:13
24-27/1/94: Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00470
71:26
20:02
17:44
12:27
21:13
25/8/76 Kobe: Jean Jean CD JJGD-2001-2017 (reissue)
69:52
19:12
18:30
10:25
21:45
25/8/76 Kobe: Jean-Jean CD JJ008-019 (full set)
69:52
19:12
18:30
10:25
21:45
11/9/1986: JVC CD VDC-1211
64:51
19:19
16:04
9:11
20:22
11/9/1986: JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set) .
64:51
19:19
16:04
9:11
20:22
11/9/1986: JVC CD VICC 60281-91 (full set)
64:51
19:19
16:04
9:11
20:22
11/9/1986: Tower Records SACD Set GCAC-1018-20
64:51
19:19
16:04
9:11
20:22
Mar-81: DG CD 429 025-2 (full set)
66:17
19:13
17:10
10:21
19:33
Mar-81: DG LP 2560 022
66:17
19:13
17:10
10:21
19:33
Mar-81: DG LP 2740 253 (full set)
66:17
19:13
17:10
10:21
19:33
16/3/78: Lucky Ball LB-0067
57:00
17:40
15:21
6:05
17:40
7-9/10/91: Decca CD 436 154
67:13
19:39
18:13
9:42
19:39
24-26/2/96: Koch CD KIC 3-7391-2
70:47
20:27
20:02
10:48
19:30
14-15/3/68: SWR Music SWR 19014 CD (Set)
60:39
17:58
16:02
10:40
15:56
58:21
17:40
15:10
8:11
17:20
58:21
17:40
15:10
8:11
17:20
58:21
17:40
15:10
8:11
17:20
58:21
17:40
15:10
8:11
17:20
58:21
17:40
15:10
8:11
17:20
9/7/1959: Movimento Musica LP 01.032
61:18
17:36
16:32
10:15
16:55
9/7/1959: RN Q Disc CD 97018 (Anth.Vol II).
62:23
17:48
16:39
10:30
17:26
5-7/9/44: Bearac CD BRC 3356
59:42
17:12
17:11
9:27
15:52
5-7/9/44: Centurion Classics 10 CD Set ECC 10018
59:11
17:08
16:50
9:28
15:46
5-7/9/44: Centurion Classics 10 CD Set ECC 10028
59:11
17:08
16:50
9:28
15:46
5-7/9/44: Dante Lys CD 476
60:15
17:05
17:15
9:32
16:23
5-7/9/44: Forgotten Records FR 335
60:00
17:13
17:17
9:34
15:52
5-7/9/44: Saga LP XID 5102/3
59:42
17:12
17:11
9:27
15:52
58:53
17:00
16:47
9:22
15:44
5-7/9/44: Urania LP 402
59:42
17:12
17:11
9:27
15:52
59:42
17:12
17:11
9:27
15:52
1953: Lanne Historical Collection LHC-7122
67:50
18:18
20:48
10:35
18:01
1953: Lanta Fe LF-428
67:50
18:18
20:48
10:35
18:01
14/1/51: Berlin Classics CD 821291732
64:39
19:34
17:49
8:59
18:17
14/1/51: Brilliant Classics Set 94686
64:39
19:34
17:49
8:59
18:17
14/1/51: Eterna LP 8 20 528-529
64:39
19:34
17:49
8:59
18:17
64:39
19:34
17:49
8:59
18:17
14/1/51: Scribendum CD Set SC 505
64:39
19:34
17:49
8:59
18:17
24/11/60: En Larmes CD 01-129/130
61:15
18:52
15:21
7:42
19:18
24/11/60: Memories Reverence CD Set MR 2314/2319
61:18
18:54
15:23
7:42
19:19
24/11/60: Treasures of the Earth TOE-2057
61:15
18:52
15:21
7:42
19:18
29/6/07: Jeju Philharmonic JPO-077
51:00
16:51
14:33
6:05
13:30
56:58
17:59
14:36
6:46
17:37
56:58
17:59
14:36
6:46
17:37
56:58
17:59
14:36
6:46
17:37
56:58
17:59
14:36
6:46
17:37
21/1/78: Denon CD COCO80100 full set
65:10
19:50
15:20
11:25
18:35
21/1/78: Eterna LP 827 164/165
65:10
19:50
15:20
11:25
18:35
21/1/78: Eurodisc CD 69227 (full set)
65:10
19:50
15:20
11:25
18:35
21/1/78: Eurodisc LP 300 032-445
65:10
19:50
15:20
11:25
18:35
21/1/78: Eurodisc LP 301 587-467 full set
65:10
19:50
15:20
11:25
18:35
21/1/78: RCA CD 82876.60395 full set
65:10
19:50
15:20
11:25
18:35
21/1/78: RCA CD 88843063682 (full set)
65:10
19:50
15:20
11:25
18:35
1966: Sounds Supreme CD 2S 074
66:20
20:17
16:14
11:20
18:25
50:40
15:12
14:28
7:55
13:06
50:40
15:12
14:28
7:55
13:06
50:40
15:12
14:28
7:55
13:05
50:40
15:12
14:28
7:55
13:05
50:46
15:15
14:14
7:57
12:59
50:40
15:15
14:14
7:57
12:59
50:40
15:12
14:28
7:55
13:05
50:40
15:12
14:28
7:55
13:05
50:40
15:12
14:28
7:55
13:05
9/2015: ATMA Classique CD ACD2 2708
61:42
19:08
16:23
8:13
17:58
9/2015: ATMA Classique Set ACD2 2451
61:42
19:08
16:23
8:13
17:58
1971: Klassic Haus CDR KHCD-2012-011
60:55
18:55
16:30
9:15
16:15
1971: Turnabout LP TV34415
60:55
18:55
16:30
9:15
16:15
10 and 13/12/56: Andromeda ANDRCD 9034
60:17
18:50
17:17
8:31
15:37
10 and 13/12/56: Memories Reverence MR-2516
60:17
18:50
17:17
8:31
15:37
60:54
18:54
17:18
8:30
15:47
8/3/1991: GNP CD 39
60:15
19:01
16:09
6:49
18:08
8/3/1991: Great Artists CD GA 4 66
60:15
19:01
16:09
6:49
18:08
29/11/73: Australian Eloquence 442 8557
56:50
17:52
16:16
6:09
16:33
29/11/73: Japan London LP SLC-2444
56:50
17:52
16:16
6:09
16:33
29/11/73: Japanese London CD POCL 4321
56:50
17:52
16:16
6:09
16:33
29/11/73: London CD Box Set POCL-9245/53
56:50
17:52
16:16
6:09
16:33
29/11/73: London LP 1326/38
56:50
17:52
16:16
6:09
16:33
29/11/73: London LP CS-6879
56:50
17:52
16:16
6:09
16:33
29/11/73: London open reel E-46879
56:50
17:52
16:16
6:09
16:33
29/11/73: London/Decca LP 6.35256
56:50
17:52
16:16
6:09
16:33
29/11/73: UK Decca LP SXL 6681
56:50
17:52
16:16
6:09
16:33
56:50
17:52
16:16
6:09
16:33
56:50
17:52
16:16
6:09
16:33
63:23
19:45
16:08
9:33
17:57
61:16
17:59
14:36
11:01
17:38
61:16
17:59
14:36
11:01
17:38
58:57
19:07
15:42
7:33
16:05
58:57
19:07
15:42
7:33
16:05
58:57
19:07
15:42
7:33
16:05
58:57
19:07
15:42
7:33
16:05
58:57
19:07
15:42
7:33
16:05
58:57
19:07
15:42
7:33
16:05
57:18
18:02
14:38
6:47
17:38
57:18
18:02
14:38
6:47
17:38
57:18
18:02
14:38
6:47
17:38
1990: Amati SRR 9002/1
59:30
17:44
16:26
8:35
16:25


Symphony No. 2 in C Minor
1873 First performance version. Ed. William Carragan

25-28/3/91: Camerata CD 30CM-195-6
61:29
19:33
15:50
6:43
19:23


Symphony No. 2 in C Minor
1876 Version. Ed. William Carragan [Unpublished]



Symphony No. 2 in C Minor
1877 Version. Ed. William Carragan - Removes remaining Haas anomalies

62:26
19:07
16:35
7:31
19:13
62:26
19:07
16:35
7:31
19:13
54:04
17:17
13:03
7:47
15:57
22-25/11/11: CPO 550 023-2 (Set)
56:30
16:13
17:42
7:02
15:30
22-25/11/11: CPO 777 735-2
56:30
16:13
17:42
7:02
15:30


Symphony No. 2 in C Minor
1892 Edition (Doblinger). Supervised by Cyrill Hynais with revisions by Bruckner

10/1984: Electrecord LP ST-ECE 02731/32/33
63:30
21:03
16:05
7:05
17:00
10/1984: Electrecord/Tobu CD Set ERT 1013/1022-2
63:30
21:03
16:05
7:05
17:00
4:26
4:26
4:26


Symphony No. 2 in C Minor
Transcription for Chamber Orchestra by Anthony Payne

3/2013: Linn Records SACD CDK 442
54:31
17:45
14:27
6:09
16:10


Symphony No. 2 in C Minor
Transcriptions

: Studio Weinberg CD SW 010215-2
10:34