> Discography > Symphony No. 3 in D Minor

Symphony No. 3 in D Minor

Dave's Details   Jose's Details

Peter Jan Marthe's Essay on his 2005 "Newfassung" Edition of the Symphony No. 3


Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
1873 Original Version Ed. Leopold Nowak [1977]

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
Blomstedt, HerbertDeutsches Symphony Orchestra7/1/09Antec Music AM 2985/8661:3022:2316:466:2915:41
Blomstedt, HerbertLeipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra3-4/9/98Querstand 5 CD set VKJK0507 62:40 22:45 17:52 6:41 15:10
Blomstedt, HerbertPhiladelphia Orchestra6-8/4/06Karna Musik KA-323M 62:00 23:22 16:05 6:47 15:38
Bosch, MarcusAachen Symphony Orchestra6/5/2006Coviello Classics SACD COV 30614 67:40 24:22 18:26 6:18 18:32
Iimori, NorichikaYamagata Symphony Orchestra3-4/8/09YSO Live SACD OVCX-0005465:0423:2117:486:5217:01
Inbal, EliahuBerlin Symphony Orchestra26-27/8/04RTVE (Spain) CD 65233 62:30 22:03 15:58 6:28 17:35
Inbal, EliahuCologne Radio Symphony Orchestra2/7/2004En Larmes CD ELS-04-571 61:00 21:57 16:12 6:14 16:06
Inbal, EliahuCologne Radio Symphony Orchestra6/2/2004En Larmes CD ELS-04-480 60:00 21:37 16:01 6:13 15:52
Inbal, EliahuFrankfurt Radio Symphony Orchestra15/9/82Apex CD 25646 00052 65:12 24:00 18:51 6:07 16:14
Teldec 242961 65:12 24:00 18:51 6:07 16:14
Teldec CD 0630-18715-2 65:12 24:00 18:51 6:07 16:14
Teldec CD 419724 65:12 24:00 18:51 6:07 16:14
Teldec CD 4509-91445-2 65:12 24:00 18:51 6:07 16:14
Teldec CD 8.42922 65:12 24:00 18:51 6:07 16:14
Teldec LP 6.35642 65:12 24:00 18:51 6:07 16:14
Ultima CD 85738/8012 65:12 24:00 18:51 6:07 16:14
Laxa, DiethardJugend Sinfonie Orchester Mannheim18-20/4/08Orchestra CD59:0822:3515:336:0314:58
Leinsdorf, ErichChicago Symphony Orchesra8/12/1983Lucky Ball CDR LB0030 60:14 19:47 16:58 7:00 15:35
Mast, MarkJunge Munich Philharmonie17/8/04Orchestra CD 67:53 23:55 17:12 5:47 20:59
Triptychon CD 1006 04 67:53 23:55 17:12 5:47 20:59
Nagano, KentDeutsche Symphony Orchestra2003Harmonia Mundi HMC 801817 (SACD) 68:42 26:33 17:01 6:28 18:37
Harmonia Mundi HMC 901817 (CD) 68:42 26:33 17:01 6:28 18:37
King Records CD KKCC511 68:42 26:33 17:01 6:28 18:37
Nezet-Seguin, YannickStaatskapelle Dresden22/9/08Antec Music AM 314670:0025:4820:056:2817:31
Nezet-Seguin, YannickSydney Symphony Orchestra12/8/09Antec Music AM 374169:2125:3619:596:3617:07
Norrington, RogerLondon Classical PlayersSep-95EMI CD 5561672 57:25 18:48 17:14 6:24 14:57
EMI Veritas CD 482019 2 57:25 18:48 17:14 6:24 14:57
Norrington, RogerSWR Symphony Orchestra22/5/07Haenssler Classics 93.21761:0219:5718:326:3715:56
Norrington, RogerSWR Symphony Orchestra6/10/2006Harvest Classics HC-06055 59:45 19:17 18:27 6:31 15:16
Karna Musik KA-368M 59:45 19:17 18:27 6:31 15:16
Nott, JonathanBamberg Symphony Orchestra 2-4/12/02Tudor SACD 7133 63:12 22:34 17:50 6:47 15:46
Nott, JonathanBamberg Symphony Orchestra28/7/02Sounds Supreme CD 2S-113 65:00 23:22 18:46 6:51 16:31
Nott, JonathanBamberg Symphony Orchestra29/7/02Antec Musik AM 355364:0023:0718:056:4816:06
Rozhdestvensky, GennadiUSSR Ministry of Culture Orchestra1988JapanBMG Melodiya CD BVCX38005/06 72:26 24:32 18:49 9:14 19:29
Melodiya LP C1030748 72:26 24:32 18:49 9:14 19:29
Venezia CDVE 04367 (boxed set) 72:26 24:32 18:49 9:14 19:29
Tintner, GeorgRoyal Scottish National Orchestra27-28/8/98Naxos CD 8.553454 77:43 30:34 20:37 6:47 19:22
Wildner, JohannesNeue Philharmonic Westfalen10/2001-1/2002SonArte CD SP 20 72:00 25:31 19:43 6:36 20:00
Young, SimoneHamburg Philharmonic Orchestra14-16/10/06BMG Japan SACD BVCO 37446 68:38 25:26 19:20 6:40 17:09
Oehms Classics SACD OC 624 68:38 25:26 19:20 6:40 17:09



Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
1874 Version Ed. Thomas Roeder (unpublished)

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
No Recording, No recordingsNo Recording



Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
1876 Adagio only Ed. Leopold Nowak [1980]

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
Asahina, TakashiOsaka Philharmonic16/9/83JVC CD VICC-60323 16:40
Leinsdorf, ErichChicago Symphony Orchestra8/12/1983Lucky Ball CDR LB0030 16:58
Rozhdestvensky, GennadiUSSR Ministry of Culture Orchestra1984GPR CD GPR-004 18:14
JapanBMG Melodiya CD BVCX38005/06 18:20
Melodiya CD SUCD 10-00220 18:14
Melodiya LP C10-25525009 18:14
Venezia CDVE 04271 18:22
Venezia CDVE 04367 (boxed set) 18:22
Tintner, GeorgRoyal Scottish National Orchestra1/9/1998Naxos CD 8554430 20:35
Vanska, OsmoBBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra8-10/6/00Hyperion CD CDA 67200 21:03
Wildner, JohannesNeue Philharmonie Westfalen10/2001-1/2002Naxos 8.555928-29 18:15
SonArte CD SP 20 18:15



Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
1877 Version - 4 Hand Piano Arrangement by Mahler (1-3) and Krzyzanowski (4) Ed. Raettig

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
Trenker-Speidel DuoJun-94MD G CD 330 0591-2 58:45 22:45 17:05 5:49 12:49



Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
1877 Version Ed. Leopld Nowak (with Scherzo coda) [1981]

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
Asahina, TakashiOsaka Philharmonic26/7/84JVC CD VDC-1047 61:12 20:28 15:32 7:52 17:20
JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set) 61:12 20:28 15:32 7:52 17:20
Gielen, MichaelSWR Symphony Orchestra3-5/5/1999Haenssler CD 93.031 55:30 18:29 15:43 6:55 14:08
Guschlbauer, TheodorOrechestre Philharmonique de Liege15/1/09Dirigent DIR-019858:0020:1015:057:3215:01
Haitink, BernardVienna Philharmonic23/8/92Fachmann Klassic Musik CDR 180 64:45 23:22 17:23 7:42 16:08
Haitink, BernardVienna PhilharmonicDec-88Philips CD 422 411 61:29 21:21 16:58 7:30 15:40
Philips CD 470 534 61:29 21:21 16:58 7:30 15:40
Harnoncourt, NikolausConcertgebouw Orchestra7-9/12/94Teldec CD 4509-98405 54:34 19:29 13:26 7:02 14:37
Warner Music CD WPCS 11983 54:34 19:29 13:26 7:02 14:37
Herreweghe, PhilippeRoyal Flanders Philharmonic14/12/97Kapellmeister KMS-23253:3018:5313:506:4914:18
Rahbari, AlexanderBRTN Philharmonic Brussels26-28/2/95Discover CD 920319 59:11 21:18 16:44 7:09 14:00
Sinopoli, GuiseppeStaatskapelle DresdenApr-90DG CD 431 684-2 59:11 21:08 16:08 7:15 14:40
DG D 100182 59:11 21:08 16:08 7:15 14:40
Solti, GeorgBavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra10/6/1993En Larmes 01-110 57:30 21:38 15:40 6:52 13:25
Solti, GeorgBavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra11/6/1993Arthaus Musik PAL DVD 100320 57:25 21:28 15:37 6:51 13:25
Pioneer Classics LD PC-96-118 57:25 21:28 15:37 6:51 13:25
Spectrum (Korea) DVD SP-1230 57:25 21:28 15:37 6:51 13:25
Solti, GeorgChicago Symphony Orchestra16-17/11/92London/Decca CD 440316-2andfull set 59:33 21:49 16:39 7:00 13:57
Universal Classics (Japan) UCCD 3732 59:33 21:49 16:39 7:00 13:57
Vanska, OsmoBBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra8-10/6/00Hyperion CD CDA 67200 62:36 20:53 21:03 7:15 13:24
Wildner, JohannesNeue Philharmonie Westfalen10/2001-1/2002Naxos 8.555928-29 59:30 21:23 15:38 7:17 15:10
SonArte CD SP 20 59:30 21:23 15:38 7:17 15:10



Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
1878 Version Ed. Fritz Oeser (Scherzo coda not included) Based on 1880 Stichvorlage

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
Asahina, TakashiOsaka Philharmonic28/10/77Jean Jean CD JJGD-2001-2017 (reissue) 57:38 19:41 15:05 6:57 15:55
Jean-Jean CD JJ008-019(full set) 57:38 19:41 15:05 6:57 15:55
Barenboim, DanielBerlin Philharmonic13/3/83Lucky Ball CDR 0055 62:15 21:35 17:49 7:04 16:02
Barenboim, DanielBerlin PhilharmonicDec-95Elatus 60533-2 59:15 20:50 16:14 6:51 15:20
Teldec CD 0630-13160-2 59:15 20:50 16:14 6:51 15:20
Warner Classics 2564.61891 full set 59:15 20:50 16:14 6:51 15:20
Barenboim, DanielChicago Symphony OrchestraDec-80DG CD 429 025-2 (full set) 60:23 20:48 16:49 7:22 15:24
DG LP 2560 023 60:23 20:48 16:49 7:22 15:24
DG LP 2740 253 (full set) 60:23 20:48 16:49 7:22 15:24
Barenboim, DanielOrchestre de Paris14/8/81Karna Musik KA 146M 61:30 21:04 17:17 7:09 15:44
Buente, C. A.Berlin Symphony Orchestra5/9/1957Buente CD 15:42
Dohnanyi, Christoph vonCleveland Orchestra1/6/1993London/Decca CD 443 753-2 57:17 20:33 15:11 6:57 14:36
London/Decca CD 466 333-2 57:17 20:33 15:11 6:57 14:36
Musical Heritage Soc CD 524513K 57:17 20:33 15:11 6:57 14:36
Haitink, BernardConcertgebouw Orchestra28/9-1/10/63Philips CD 442 040-2 (full set) 56:34 19:20 14:42 6:58 15:34
Philips CD 4756740 full set 56:34 19:20 14:42 6:58 15:34
Philips LP 416 859 56:34 19:20 14:42 6:58 15:34
Philips LP 6717 002 (full set) 56:34 19:20 14:42 6:58 15:34
Philips LP 835-217-AY 56:34 19:20 14:42 6:58 15:34
Philips LP 900-068 56:34 19:20 14:42 6:58 15:34
Philips SAL 3506 56:34 19:20 14:42 6:58 15:34
Horenstein, JaschaBBC Northern Symphony Orchestra3/7/63BBC Legends BBCL 4219-2 58:00 19:10 14:34 7:39 16:22
Horenstein, JaschaBBC Symphony Orchestra9/11/1957World Music Express CDR-1133/4 53:30 19:32 12:46 5:25 15:36
Kubelik, RafaelBavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra14/10/80CBS LP IM 39033 57:54 21:15 14:40 7:15 14:44
Sony 88697385852 57:54 21:15 14:40 7:15 14:44
Sony CD 39033 57:54 21:15 14:40 7:15 14:44
Sony CD SICC261 57:54 21:15 14:40 7:15 14:44
Kubelik, RafaelBavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra30/1/70Audite SACD 92.543 57:48 20:14 16:11 7:00 14:24
Bells of St. Florian 57:30 20:04 16:02 7:01 14:15
En Larmes 02-215 57:16 20:00 16:00 6:52 14:11
Great Artists CD GA 4.7 57:16 20:00 16:00 6:52 14:11
Kubelik, RafaelConcertgebouw Orchestra28/1/54RN Q Disc CD 97018 (Anth. Vol. III) 57:17 18:43 14:55 7:24 16:10
Kubelik, RafaelNew York Philharmonic26/4/82Vibrato VLL-27262:1521:3417:067:2316:05
Lee, Dong-HoJeju Philharmonic Orchestra8/6/2006Jeju Philharmonic JPO-075 52:27 18:48 13:28 6:48 13:23
Matacic, Lovro vonBudapest Symphony Orchestra16/5/79Sardana Records CDR 144 60:02 21:07 15:34 7:25 15:56
Matacic, Lovro vonPhilharmonia Orchestra23/7/83BBC BBCL 4079 59:30 20:36 15:22 7:06 16:19
Matacic, Lovro vonVienna Symphony Orchestra9/6/1982GNP CDR 75 57:30 19:47 15:04 7:32 15:00
Great Artists CD 4-13 57:30 19:47 15:04 7:32 15:00
Halloo CD 07/08 57:30 19:47 15:04 7:32 15:00
Meteor CD-028 57:30 19:47 15:04 7:32 15:00
Re! Discover RED 47 57:30 19:47 15:04 7:32 15:00
Rozhdestvensky, GennadiUSSR Ministry of Culture Orchestra1984JapanBMG Melodiya CD BVCX38003/04 62:43 21:56 17:04 7:41 15:40
Melodiya LP C10 25525009 62:41 21:59 17:06 7:39 15:39
Venezia CDVE 04240 (boxed set) 62:43 21:56 17:04 7:41 15:40
Venezia CDVE 04367 (boxed set) 62:43 21:56 17:04 7:41 15:40
Rubahn (Pseudonym), GerdBerlin Symphony Orchestra1952-1954Allegro-Royale LP 1597 58:28 21:06 15:50 6:38 14:53
Lanta Fe LF-430 58:28 21:06 15:50 6:38 14:53



Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
1889 Version (aka 1888/89) Ed. Leopold Nowak [1959]

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
Asahina, TakashiNew Japan Philharmonic12/12/1996Japan Columbia DVD COBB-90004 62:00 21:43 14:45 7:00 18:32
Japan Image Comm. LD TOLH 804 62:00 21:43 14:45 7:00 18:32
Asahina, TakashiOsaka Philharmonic3-6/10/93Canyon SACD PCCL 60016 61:21 22:59 16:37 7:51 13:54
Pony Canyon CD PCCL 00210 61:21 22:59 16:37 7:51 13:54
Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00471 61:21 22:59 16:37 7:51 13:54
Boehm, KarlVienna PhilharmonicSep-70Decca LP SXL 6505 56:36 22:00 14:44 6:54 12:58
JB LP 126 56:36 22:00 14:44 6:54 12:58
London LP CS 6717 56:36 22:00 14:44 6:54 12:58
London POCL 9969 56:36 22:00 14:44 6:54 12:58
London/Decca CD 425032 56:36 22:00 14:44 6:54 12:58
London/Decca CD 448-098-2df2 56:36 22:00 14:44 6:54 12:58
London/Decca CD 503229 56:36 22:00 14:44 6:54 12:58
Universal Classics UCCD 4423 56:36 22:00 14:44 6:54 12:58
Universal Classics UCCD 9187 56:36 22:00 14:44 6:54 12:58
Universal Classics UCCD-9642 56:36 22:00 14:44 6:54 12:58
Bolton, IvorMozarteum Orchestra25&27/10/07BMG BVCO 3805957:3621:1415:427:0613:13
Oehms Classics OC 72257:3621:1415:427:0613:13
Celibidache, SergiuMunich Philharmonic12/10/93World Music Express WME-S-129661:1523:4117:146:4713:56
Celibidache, SergiuMunich Philharmonic14/9/91En Larmes ELS 02-203 62:19 21:06 16:29 7:38 14:06
Great Artists CD GA 4 4 62:19 21:06 16:29 7:38 14:06
Memories CD 1053/4 62:19 21:06 16:29 7:38 14:06
Sardana CDR 0125 62:19 21:06 16:29 7:38 14:06
Theo van der Burg CD 4 62:19 21:06 16:29 7:38 14:06
Celibidache, SergiuMunich Philharmonic19-20/3/87EMI CDC 5 56689 2 64:35 25:07 16:38 7:46 15:04
EMI CDS 5 56688 2 64:35 25:07 16:38 7:46 15:04
EMI CMS 5 67732 2 64:35 25:07 16:38 7:46 15:04
EMI TOCE 11612 64:35 25:07 16:38 7:46 15:04
EMI TOCE 9801/9812 64:35 25:07 16:38 7:46 15:04
EMI TOCE 9895 64:35 25:07 16:38 7:46 15:04
Celibidache, SergiuMunich Philharmonic22/4/93Vibrato VLL 30473:3028:0319:488:3016:53
Celibidache, SergiuStuttgart Radio Symphony Orch.1981World Music Express WME--S-1275/659:3022:5316:376:3513:04
Celibidache, SergiuStuttgart Radio Symphony Orch.24/11/80Bells of St.Florian CD AB1 60:52 23:31 17:09 6:48 13:26
DG CD 10256/9 61:14 23:40 17:12 6:56 13:26
DG CD 459 663-2 61:14 23:40 17:12 6:56 13:26
DG CD 477 5136 61:14 23:40 17:12 6:56 13:26
Disco Archivia CD 1123 60:52 23:31 17:09 6:48 13:26
Exclusive CD 93T59 61:35 23:40 17:15 7:01 13:39
Meteor CD 008 61:35 23:40 17:15 7:01 13:39
Chailly, RiccardoRSO BerlinMay-85London/Decca CD 417093-2 55:51 20:41 15:49 7:01 12:20
London/Decca LP 417093-1 55:51 20:41 15:49 7:01 12:20
Colomer, EdmonBarcelona Symphony Orchestra1/2000Els Concerts dels Diumentes CD 13 53:13 20:22 14:16 7:19 11:10
Davies, Dennis RussellBruckner Orchestra Linz27/2/05Arte Nova CD 82876 84321 2 58:13 22:01 15:41 7:04 12:31
BMG CD BVCE 38106 58:13 22:01 15:41 7:04 12:31
Frank, Hans-PeterStaatskapelle Weimar16/1/92POA CD Classic 75013 57:36 21:38 15:11 7:19 13:24
Frantz, JustusPhilharmonie der Nationen2000Philharmonie de Nationen JE 21 53:31 20:23 13:59 7:11 11:58
Fruehbeck de Burgos, RafaelDresden Philharmonic4-7/10/06Genuin CD Set GEN 88139 57:54 22:03 15:20 7:44 12:45
Genuin GEN 87086 57:54 22:03 15:20 7:44 12:45
Fruehbeck de Burgos, RafaelRSO Berlin1993Berlin RSO CD (scherzo only) 7:07
Gergiev, ValeryRotterdam Philharmonic Orchestra12/9/08Antec Music AM 3032/3353:1520:2115:076:3611:08
Haenchen, HartmutNetherlands Philharmonic1987Denon COCO 78032 53:49 22:00 14:17 6:12 11:20
Laserlight CD 14 002 53:49 22:00 14:17 6:12 11:20
Netherlands Philharmonic CD 1002 53:49 22:00 14:17 6:12 11:20
Hager, LeopoldSinfonica de RTVE30/11/07Antec Music CD AM 234352:1520:3113:156:4511:48
Herbig, GunterScottish National Orchestra19/8/06Sun Jay Classics SUCD-15-K 54:30 20:16 14:00 6:59 13:03
Hindemith, PaulMannheim Theatre Orchestra3/5/1963Treasures of the Earth TOE-2006 54:00 19:47 14:45 7:00 12:41
Iimori, TaijiroTokyo City Philharmonic18/1/01Fontec FOCD 9149 57:30 20:52 16:26 7:07 12:52
Janowski, MarekPhilharmonic Orchestra of Monte-Carlo25/9/05Harvest Classics HC-06139 53:00 20:33 14:10 6:26 11:13
Jansons, MarissBavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra19/3/05Antec Music CD AM2287 57:00 22:24 14:11 7:29 12:31
Encore DVD 133042 57:00 22:24 14:11 7:29 12:31
Jansons, MarissBavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra21/1/05Bavarian R.S.O. Subscription CD . 56:35 22:06 13:52 7:14 12:42
Don Industriale CD DI-05-027A 56:00 22:04 13:50 7:07 12:52
En Larmes ELS-05-641 56:00 21:41 13:53 7:01 12:28
Karna Musik KA-133M (Bonus CD) 56:00 21:41 13:53 7:01 12:28
Jansons, MarissConcertgebouw Orchestra28/8/08Antec Music AM 321457:0023:2313:506:5612:40
Jansons, MarissConcertgebouw Orchestra5/9/08SunJay Classics SUCD-104K57:4522:5514:057:1012:35
Jansons, MarissConcertgebouw Orchestra8/2/2007Harvest Classics HC 06064 56:00 22:10 14:07 7:01 12:35
Radio Nederland Concertgebouw Now 2008 Set 56:00 22:10 14:07 7:01 12:35
Jansons, MarissConcertgebouw Orchestra of Amsterdam7-8/2/07 and 28/8/08RCO Live SACD RCO 0900256:4322:5613:486:5612:37
Jochum, EugenBavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra8/1/1967DG CD 429 079-2 (full set) 53:01 19:59 15:12 7:14 10:36
DG LP 104 808 29:01
DG LP 139 133 53:01 19:59 15:12 7:14 10:36
DG LP 2740-136 (full set) 53:01 19:59 15:12 7:14 10:36
Universal Music UCCG 3994 53:01 19:59 15:12 7:14 10:36
Jochum, EugenCologne Radio Symphony Orchestra7/9/1976Antec Music CD AM 2058 55:00 20:48 15:34 7:28 11:05
Cult of Classical Music CD 1023 55:00 20:48 15:34 7:28 11:05
Memories CD ME-1057/60 55:00 20:48 15:34 7:28 11:05
Re Discover RED 23 55:00 20:48 15:34 7:28 11:05
Sardana CDR 207/208 55:00 20:48 15:34 7:28 11:05
Jochum, EugenStaatskapelle Dresden22-27/1/77Basic Classics CD TRa 012 54:24 20:31 15:27 7:30 10:56
Electrola LP ASD 4009 54:24 20:31 15:27 7:30 10:56
EMI CD CZS 5 68652 2 54:24 20:31 15:27 7:30 10:56
EMI CD CZS 7 62935 2 (full set) 54:24 20:31 15:27 7:30 10:56
EMI Toshiba TOCE 13484 54:24 20:31 15:27 7:30 10:56
Eterna LP 8 27 138-139 54:24 20:31 15:27 7:30 10:56
Karajan, Herbert vonBerlin Philharmonic21/9/80DG CD 413 362-2 56:49 21:56 16:21 6:53 11:39
DG CD 429-648-2GSE9 (full set) 56:49 21:56 16:21 6:53 11:39
DG LP 2532 007 56:49 21:56 16:21 6:53 11:39
DG LP 2535 265 56:49 21:56 16:21 6:53 11:39
DG LP 2740264 (full set) 56:49 21:56 16:21 6:53 11:39
Kegel, HerbertLeipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra20/3/86Lucky Ball CDR 0020 57:00 21:26 14:49 7:41 12:50
Weitblick CD SSS0042 57:00 21:28 14:51 7:43 12:45
Kegel, HerbertLeipzig Radio Symphony Orchestra6/6/1978ODE Classics CD ODCL-1012 52:21 19:39 13:53 7:02 11:45
ODE Classics CD ODCLBOX3 52:21 19:39 13:53 7:02 11:45
Komatsu, KazuhikoBruckner Orchestra of Nagoya29/6/03BON CD 016/017 60:52 23:24 17:36 7:07 13:50
Kuhn, MatthaisAkademisches Orchester Freiberg10/2/2006Waterpipe Records CD 957 642 63:25 27:44 16:00 6:42 12:59
Maazel, LorinBavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra2/4/2000En Larmes CD ELS 02 161 54:30 20:35 14:15 6:44 12:57
Maazel, LorinBavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra30/1/99Bavarian Radio Set 58:10 22:25 15:05 6:54 13:15
Maazel, LorinNew York Philharmonic9-11/6/05Karna Musik KA 198M 57:30 22:01 14:52 6:57 13:30
Maazel, LorinRSO BerlinDec-67Concert Hall LP SMSC 2567 51:42 19:10 13:26 6:44 12:22
Festival Classique LP 406 51:42 19:10 13:26 6:44 12:22
Maazel, LorinVienna Philharmonic16/5/85Cult of Classical Music CD COCOM-1034 58:30 22:25 15:43 7:13 13:08
Lucky Ball LB-0017 58:30 22:25 15:43 7:13 13:08
Maazel, LorinVienna Philharmonic9/6/1996Belsona Classics BECL 0053/0054 58:50 22:36 15:45 6:59 13:25
Belsona Classics BECL-0053/0054 58:50 22:36 15:45 6:59 13:25
GNP CD 42 58:50 22:36 15:45 6:59 13:25
Great Artists CD GA 4 69 58:50 22:36 15:45 6:59 13:25
Mandeal, CristianCluj-Napoca Symphony Orchestra10/1984Electrecord LP ST-ECE 02731/32/33 63:00 21:15 18:23 8:41 14:36
Masur, KurtFrench National Orchestra18/9/03Disclosure CD DS 0034-2 57:00 21:34 13:34 7:27 14:16
En Larmes ELS-03-460 57:00 21:34 13:34 7:27 14:16
Masur, KurtFrench National Orchestra21/11/08Dirigent DIR 0406 57:0021:4713:237:2114:23
Masur, KurtLeipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra7/12/1977Denon CD COCO80100 full set 58:12 21:50 14:37 7:20 14:25
Edel Classics LGO CD Set 0002202CCC 58:12 21:50 14:37 7:20 14:25
Eterna LP 827 288/289 58:12 21:50 14:37 7:20 14:25
Eurodisc CD 69227 full set 58:12 21:50 14:37 7:20 14:25
Eurodisc LP 300 032-445 58:12 21:50 14:37 7:20 14:25
Eurodisc LP 301 587-467 full set 58:12 21:50 14:37 7:20 14:25
RCA CD 82876.60395 full set 58:12 21:50 14:37 7:20 14:25
Meichnen (Pseudonym), HansAmsterdam Royal PhilharmonicExclusiv CD 11 542 8:11
Nelsons, AndrisNordwest Deutsche Philharmonie26/10/07Nordwest Deutsche Philharmonie CD 58:00 22:34 15:38 6:58 12:40
Neumann, VaclavLeipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra1966BBC Transcription CN 0448 55:30 20:24 15:00 7:01 12:49
Otterloo, Willem vanAmerican Symphony Orchestra28/1/69Disco Archivia 454 49:16 18:56 12:33 6:26 11:17
Park, Eun-SeongSuwon Philharmonic21/6/05KBS Media (DVD) 61:45 25:07 15:57 7:10 13:27
Paternostro, RobertoWuerttemberg Philharmonie Reutlingen18/7/98Antes Edition SCH.3112 (Complete set) 56:37 21:50 15:04 6:47 12:05
Balance CD Bal-2007-1 56:37 21:50 15:04 6:47 12:05
Rosbaud, HansSouthwest German Radio Symphony Orchestra17/12/60Arkadia CD 772.1 54:24 19:39 14:51 7:38 12:16
Rozhdestvensky, GennadiDresden State Opera Orchestra4/8/1976Kapellmeister KMS-047/8 57:00 21:06 15:43 7:47 13:05
Lucky Ball CDR 0015 56:46 20:59 15:32 7:38 12:37
Rozhdestvensky, GennadiOslo Philharmonic2/3/2006Karna Musik KA-308M 59:15 23:40 13:55 7:53 13:27
Sanderling, KurtBavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra10/10/1985Bells of St.Florian CD AB9 58:14 20:47 14:57 7:18 14:49
En Larmes CD 03 364 58:14 20:47 14:57 7:18 14:49
Sanderling, KurtBerlin Philharmonic10/10/1990Vibrato VLL-204 61:00 22:32 16:13 7:17 15:04
Sanderling, KurtBerlin Philharmonic2/10/1990Fachmann Klassic Musik CDR 36 59:15 21:23 15:12 7:17 15:04
Sanderling, KurtBerlin Radio Symphony Orchestra (East)7/9/2001GNP CD GNP-115 65:30 24:07 16:35 7:26 17:02
Sounds Supreme CD 2S 008 65:30 24:09 16:35 7:26 17:03
Sanderling, KurtConcertgebouw Orchestra8/11/96Antec Music CD AM 2758/5961:0023:1415:567:1614:33
Sanderling, KurtNew York Philharmonic13/7/73World Music Express WME-M 1079 56:30 20:12 15:01 6:47 14:18
Sanderling, KurtOrchestre de la Suisse Romande8/11/2000En Larmes 01/74 59:30 22:25 14:40 7:19 15:03
Sanderling, KurtSwiss Festival Orchestra17/8/83Lucky Ball CDR LB 0004 58:30 21:24 15:49 7:16 14:08
Sawallisch, WolfgangPhiladelphia Orchestra8/10/2002Philadelphia Orch. Download 53:56 20:53 13:40 6:46 12:35
Schneidt, Hanns-MartinBerlin PhilharmonicFeb-86Karna Musik KA-236M 58:00 22:03 15:39 6:56 13:16
Segal, UriBerlin Philharmonic6/3/74Lanne Historical Collection LHC-714556:3021:0314:507:2013:15
Lanta Fe LF-42956:3021:0314:507:2013:15
Sieghart, MartinBruckner Orchestra Linz24-26/2/95Camerata CD 285 and full set 59:20 23:36 15:45 7:22 13:24
Skrowaczewski, StanislawMinnesota Orchestra5/10/2001Minnesota Orchestra Centennial Set 61:57 22:00 17:03 7:35 14:58
Skrowaczewski, StanislawMunich Philharmonic1980"0""0""0" Classics CD 032 56:00 19:59 15:45 7:26 12:46
Skrowaczewski, StanislawNetherlands Radio Symphony Orchestra28/3/04Dirigent DIR-002856:1619:2016:127:0513:37
Skrowaczewski, StanislawSaarland Radio Symphony OrchestraOct-96Arte Nova CD 74321 65412 2 55:20 18:59 15:36 7:03 14:23
Oehms Classics CD OC212 55:20 18:59 15:36 7:03 14:23
Skrowaczewski, StanislawWarsaw National PhilharmonicFeb-81Muza LP SX 2093 54:00 18:57 15:21 6:57 12:30
Steinberg, ReinhardBavarian Physician Orchestra27-28/5/06Orchestra CD 2006 52:46 20:29 12:58 6:53 12:16
Tennstedt, KlausBavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra4/11/1976Bells of St.Florian CD AB4 52:26 19:40 14:38 6:47 11:01
Great Artists CD GA 4 20 52:26 19:40 14:38 6:47 11:01
Profil Classics CD PH04093 52:10 19:42 14:41 6:51 10:55
Re Discover CD RED 85 52:26 19:40 14:38 6:47 11:01
Wakasugi, HiroyukiNHK Symphony Orchestra26/2/96RCA CD BVCC-751 59:40 22:38 15:28 7:18 14:00
Wand, GunterCologne Radio Symphony Orchestra17/1/81BMG (Japan) BVCC 38174 55:05 21:25 13:42 6:41 12:37
BMG/RCA CD 60078 and full set 55:05 21:25 13:42 6:41 12:37
EMI CDC 7 47744 2 55:05 21:25 13:42 6:41 12:37
Harmonia Mundi LP 065-99 923 55:05 21:25 13:42 6:41 12:37
RCA CD 09026 63933 2 55:05 21:25 13:42 6:41 12:37
Wand, GunterNDR Symphony Orchestra12-14/1/92BMG VHS 53:52 20:55 13:10 6:44 12:43
BMG/RCA CD 09026-61374-2 53:52 20:55 13:10 6:44 12:43
Japan BMG CD BVCC 37024-31 53:52 20:55 13:10 6:44 12:43
Wand, GunterNDR Symphony Orchestra22/12/85Cult of Classical COCOM CD 1018 53:45 21:00 13:21 6:28 12:42
Sardana CDR 130 53:45 21:00 13:21 6:28 12:42
Wildner, JohannesNeue Philharmonic Westfalen10/2001-1/2002Naxos 8.555928-29 50:00 17:35 13:23 6:39 12:21
SonArte CD SP 20 50:00 17:35 13:23 6:39 12:21



Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
1890 Thorough revision Bruckner with Joseph and Franz Schalk Ed. Theodor Raettig

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
Adler, F. CharlesVienna Symphony Orchestra9/4/1953Spa Records LP 30/31 53:44 20:55 13:04 6:40 12:47
Andreae, VolkmarVienna Symphony Orchestra11-13/1/55Bearac Reissues CD BRC-1822 (LP transfer) 51:0019:2713:006:4311:53
Epic LP LC 3218 50:27 19:03 12:50 6:36 11:40
Forgotten Records FR-185 50:4119:1612:566:5611:44
Philips LP A00273L 50:27 19:03 12:50 6:36 11:40
Philips LP GL 5697 50:27 19:03 12:50 6:36 11:40
Andreae, VolkmarVienna Symphony Orchestra14/1&5/2/53Music and Arts CD Set 122750:4818:4913:026:4711:56
Barbirolli, JohnHalle Orrchestra18/12/64BBC Legends BBCL 4161-2 53:00 18:54 13:41 6:59 13:12
Fekete, ZoltanMozarteum Orchestra1950Bearac CD BRC-2818 48:28 18:39 12:30 6:29 10:47
Concert Artist LPA 1018 49:56 19:00 12:45 6:30 11:13
Concert Hall CHC 65 49:56 19:00 12:45 6:30 11:13
Concert Hall LP CHS1065 47:35 19:00 12:45 4:21 11:13
Concerteum CR 223 47:35 19:00 12:45 4:21 11:13
Eurochord LPG 602 47:35 19:00 12:45 4:21 11:13
Forgotten Records FR 19448:3118:4012:336:2710:48
Qualiton LP HLPX 1047 47:35 19:00 12:45 4:21 11:13
Remington LP 199-138 49:56 19:00 12:45 6:30 11:13
Serenade CD SEDR-2032 48:28 18:39 12:30 6:29 10:47
Goehr, WalterNetherlands Philharmonic1954Concert Hall LP CHS1195 51:24 17:50 16:03 5:57 11:34
Concert Hall Society LP CHS2018 51:24 17:50 16:03 5:57 11:34
Musical Masterpiece Society LP 2018 51:24 17:50 16:03 5:57 11:34
Jochum, EugenHamburg State Orchestra13-15/5/44Music and Arts CD-1100 56:15 20:17 17:24 6:59 10:57
Tahra CD 382-385 56:23 20:35 17:40 7:08 11:10
Tahra CD TAH 457 56:15 20:17 17:24 6:59 10:57
Jochum, Georg LudwigStuttgart Radio Symphony Orchestra19/11/64Tahra CD 164 and full set 51:54 19:04 13:54 6:55 12:01
Knappertsbusch, HansBavarian State Orchestra11/10/1954Andromeda ANDR CD 9010 (set) 51:06 18:05 12:37 7:12 13:10
Archipel CD ARPCD 0219 50:45 18:00 12:31 7:00 13:03
Centurion Classics 10 CD Set ECC 10018
Centurion Classics 10 CD Set ECC 10028
Green Hill CD 0019 51:06 18:05 12:37 7:12 13:12
King KICC 2153 50:45 18:00 12:31 7:00 13:03
Music and Arts CD 257 51:06 18:05 12:37 7:12 13:12
Orfeo d'Or 576 021 50:45 18:00 12:31 7:00 13:03
Re Discover RED 37 51:06 18:05 12:37 7:12 13:12
Knappertsbusch, HansMunich Philharmonic16/1/64Chaconne CHCD 1002 59:45 22:14 13:54 7:53 14:44
Living Stage CD 1003 60:01 22:26 14:07 7:57 15:31
Melodram CD GM40008 (set) 60:01 22:26 14:07 7:57 15:31
Seven Seas CD KICC 2359 59:45 22:13 13:57 7:55 14:59
Knappertsbusch, HansNorth German Radio Symphony Orchestra15/1/62Discocorp LP RR-496 60:54 22:30 14:44 7:36 16:04
En Larmes 01-99 60:54 22:30 14:44 7:36 16:04
King K30Y 263 60:54 22:04 14:04 7:36 16:04
King KICC 2410 60:54 22:04 14:04 7:36 16:04
Living Stage LS-1019 60:40 22:40 14:45 7:33 15:42
Music and Arts CD 1028 60:54 22:30 14:44 7:36 16:04
Tahra TAH CD 132/135 60:32 22:26 14:40 7:41 15:45
Knappertsbusch, HansVienna Philharmonic1-3/4/54Andromeda CD ANR 2511 53:49 19:08 14:05 7:21 13:14
Decca BLK 21020 53:49 19:08 14:05 7:21 13:14
Decca Eclipse LP ECS 553 53:45 19:06 14:04 7:21 13:14
Decca LP LXT 2967 53:49 19:08 14:05 7:21 13:14
Decca SMB 25039 53:49 19:08 14:05 7:21 13:14
Everest LP 3300 53:49 19:08 14:05 7:21 13:14
Japanese London K30Y 1030 53:49 19:08 14:05 7:21 13:14
King KICC 210 54:30 19:13 14:07 7:25 13:18
Living Stage LS 1019S 53:49 19:08 14:05 7:21 13:14
London LP LL 1044 53:49 19:08 14:05 7:21 13:14
Palladio/Enterprise CD 4111 53:45 19:06 14:04 7:21 13:14
Testament CD SBT 1339 54:30 19:13 14:07 7:25 13:18
Universal Music CD UCCD 9237 54:30 19:13 14:07 7:25 13:18
Knappertsbusch, HansVienna Philharmonic14/2/60Altus CD 071 55:24 20:20 13:36 7:25 13:18
Konrath, AntonVienna Symphony Orchestra10/10/1928Abruckner.com BSVD-01016:35
EMI CD CDHC 5 66206-2 4:19
HMV AN 192 4:19
HMV C 2659 4:19
HMV EH 844 4:19
Symposium CD 1258 4:19
Victor 78's 4:19
Lehmann, FritzOrchester des Deutschlandsenders und Reichssenders Berlin28/6/40Deutsche Rundfunk Transcription 78's 8:12 8:12
Noguchi, TakeoFurtwaengler Institute Philharmonic1999Mukei CD MT 99014/5 53:00 18:48 13:03 7:14 13:26
Rozhdestvensky, GennadiLarge SO of Soviet Radio and TV13/2/72Eurodisc Melodiya LP 86 612MK 54:30 19:45 14:52 7:42 12:00
Icone CD ICN 9428-2 54:46 19:54 15:01 7:47 12:05
Melodiya LP CM03579-80 54:37 19:49 14:58 7:46 12:04
Russian Revelation CD 10007 54:30 19:45 14:52 7:42 12:00
Westminster LP WGS-8327 54:30 19:45 14:52 7:42 12:00
Rozhdestvensky, GennadiUSSR Ministry of Culture Orchestra1988Japan BMG/Melodiya CD BVCX38005/06 59:21 22:00 16:02 8:01 12:55
Melodiya LP C1031047 58:47 21:55 16:00 8:03 12:50
Venezia CDVE 04367 (boxed set) 59:21 22:00 16:02 8:01 12:55
Sanderling, KurtLeipzig Gewandhaus OrchestraJun-63Berlin Classics CD 21512 64:02 23:05 17:28 7:39 15:28
Corona Classics CD Set CCC 0002342 64:02 23:05 17:30 7:35 15:35
Edel CD 0002202CCC 64:02 23:05 17:28 7:39 15:28
Electrola LP C153-28 943/44 64:02 23:05 17:28 7:39 15:28
Electrola LP E/STE 91357-8 64:02 23:05 17:28 7:39 15:28
Eterna LP 820 435-6 64:02 23:05 17:28 7:39 15:28
Eterna LP 826 509-510 64:02 23:05 17:30 7:35 15:35
Schuricht, CarlVienna Philharmonic2-4/12/65EMI CD TOCE 6841-43 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
German EMI CD CDZ260090529242 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
HMV CD 292428 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
HMV LP ASD 2284 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
HMV SME 91500 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
HMV SME 91500 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
HMV SME 91500 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
Medici Masters MM 016 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
Preiser CD 90409 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
Seraphim LP S-60090 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
Testament Classics LP ASD 2284 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
Toshiba EMI CD TOCE3404 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
Trianon LP TRI 33320-23 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
World Record Club ST 1089 55:26 19:07 14:41 7:29 13:53
Szell, GeorgeCleveland Orchestra27/1/66Disco Archivia DA-338 56:00 21:05 15:27 7:26 12:04
World Music Express WME CDR-1234/556:0020:5015:177:2012:01
Szell, GeorgeCleveland Orchestra28-29/1/66CBS LP 61072 55:13 20:04 15:31 7:18 12:20
Columbia LP ML 4297 55:13 20:04 15:31 7:18 12:20
Columbia LP MS-6897 55:13 20:04 15:31 7:18 12:20
Columbia SAX 5294 55:13 20:04 15:31 7:18 12:20
Epic LP BC 1362 55:13 20:04 15:31 7:18 12:20
Sony CD SB2K 53519 53:44 20:03 15:27 5:53 12:21
Sony MPK 45880 55:13 20:04 15:31 7:18 12:20
Szell, GeorgeStaatskapelle Dresden2/8/1965Andante CD AN 2180 52:12 18:05 13:02 7:00 12:00
DeAgostini FS96CD32-2 52:12 19:12 13:44 7:14 12:00
Sony CD SICC 460 52:12 18:05 13:02 7:00 12:00
Sony CD SMK 68 448 52:12 19:12 13:44 7:14 12:00
Szell, GeorgeVienna Philharmonic5/6/1966Antec Music CD AM 2107 54:00 20:16 14:39 7:18 11:42
Encore DVD 134117 54:00 20:16 14:39 7:18 11:42
Toshiba EMI LD TOLW 3741 54:00 20:16 14:39 7:18 11:42



Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
2005 'Neufassung' reconstructed from the 1873-1876-1877-1889 editions. Ed. Peter Jan Marthe

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
Marthe, Peter JanEurupean Philharmonic Orchestra19/8/05Orchestra CD 88:00 27:58 27:00 12:08 20:33



Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
2006 'Neufassung' reconstructed from the 1873-1876-1877-1889 editions. Ed. Peter Jan Marthe

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
Marthe, Peter JanEurupean Philharmonic Orchestra19/8/05Preiser CD PR 90715 88:00 27:58 12:08 27:00 20:33



Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
Symfonie No. 3 "Final Performing Version" (Endgiltige Konzertfassung) edited by Joseph Kanz [2005]

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
Schneider, UrsGeorges Enescu Philharmonic13/12/07Orchestra CD55:3620:3313:497:1014:02



Symphony No. 3 in D Minor
Transcriptions

ConductorOrchestraDatesLabelTotal Time1st2nd3rd4th
Trenkner and Speidel Piano DuoJun-94MDG CD330 0591-2 58:45 22:45 17:05 5:49 12:49
Kahn, EmilStuttgart Festival OrchestraunknownMusic Minus One CD MMO 3806 6:57
Music Minus One LP MMO 136 6:57
List, KarlOrchester des Reichssender Muenchen (Blaeser)30/6/1937Polydor 78 MCHN 37453 0:11
Stender, Ernst-ErichOrgan of St Marys in Luebeck2001Ornament CD 11458 51:53 18:40 14:13 6:18 12:40